Evidence Article Working Group
This working group will develop an article that outlines the need for robust evidence and provide expert recommendations on the types of studies and protocols that should be run including a recommendation check-list (or other easily applicable format) for study design.
Manuscript Drafts
Here you will find the latest draft of the article for download. After making your edits, please save the document with your initials following the previous editor’s initials (e.g. Manuscript 3_SELF_Evidence_v1_ab cd ef gh.docx) and upload your edited and/or commented Evidence Article draft to the drafts folder. We are aiming to submit this suite of articles to the Lancet or BMJ in February or March of 2024.
Key Resources
| Title | Authors | Date posted | Summary | Tags | Shared by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Authorship Guidelines | SELF | 1/24/2024 | Lancet information for Authors, Authorship criteria, Authorship contributions, Example of Corporate Authorship | Corporate, group, collaborators, group | Megan Kern |
| SELF Symposium Working Session 5 (Evidence) | SELF | 11/10/2023 | This spreadsheet summarizes the findings from the 2023 SELF Symposium working session 5. | symposium, self, excel, spreadsheet, voting, votes, table, tables, data, action, actions, guidelines | Catherine Mohr |
| Facilitation Notes: Evidence Generation & Clinical Study Protocols | SELF | 1/16/2024 | This document summarizes the instructions given to the working group participants. Including the session agenda, facilitator guides, wall set-up, and slides posted during the discussions. | symposium, self, methods, facilitator, facilitation, discussion, handouts, instructions, rule, voting, votes, action, actions, guidelines | Megan Kern |
| Chatham House Rule | Chatham House | 12/04/2023 | When a meeting, or part thereof, is held under the Chatham House Rule, participants are free to use the information received, but neither the identity nor the affiliation of the speaker(s), nor that of any other participant, may be revealed. | Chatham, house, Chatham house, rule, participate, anonymous, reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Mimi Wainwright |
| Advancing Simulation Research Scholarship | Dimitrios Stefanidis | 12/13/2023 | Presentation given by Dr. Dimitrios Stefanidis at the 2023 SELF Symposium. | Slides, powerpoint, power, point, presentation, ppt, Evidence, Priorities, Prioritisation, Prioritization | Dimitrios Stefanidis |
| Moving the Needle: Simulation's Impact on Patient Outcomes | Cox, et al. | 12/13/2023 | In this review, the authors conduct a comprehensive search and categorization of studies reporting outcomes of simulation training. | review, simulator, simulation, training, Kirkpatrick model, evaluation, patient outcomes, reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Dimitrios Stefanidis |
| The value proposition of simulation-based education | Cook, et al. | 12/04/2023 | This paper summarizes the information from a special panel on the value assessment of simulation based training given the resources required for implementation and defines research priorities for the field. | simulation, training, value, judgement, pros, cons, pros and cons, reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Mimi Wainwright |
| What are the Top Research Priorities in Surgical Simulation and How Can They Be Best Addressed? Results From a Multidisciplinary Consensus Conference | Stefanidis, et al. | 12/13/2023 | Findings from a research summit to define the top priorities in simulation-based surgical education where additional research would have the highest potential to advance the field and develop proposals that would address the identified research priorities. | Delphi methodology, delphi, method, consensus, simulation, simulation-based, surgical, surgery, education, training, reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Dimitrios Stefanidis |
| Global Surgical Training Challenge | SELF | 1/24/2024 | Information on the Global Surgery Training Challenge. | intuitive foundation, challenge, self, grantees, finalists, TFF, ALL-SAFE, allsafe, Crashsavers, amosmile, reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Mimi Wainwright |
| Explanation of the Kirkpatrick Model | Kirkpatrick, et al. | 1/19/2024 | A how-to book, designed for practitioners in the training field who plan, implement, and evaluate training programs. | reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Mimi Wainwright |
| APA Dictionary of Psychology | American Psychological Association | 1/19/2024 | Definition of "validity": the degree to which empirical evidence and theoretical rationales support the adequacy and appropriateness of conclusions drawn from some form of assessment. | reference, article, paper, bibliography, works cited | Mimi Wainwright |
Working Group Members
A full list of members and their email addresses is available here.
| Responsible | Consulted |
|---|---|
| Deb Rooney | Chisom Rachel Udeigwe-Okeke |
| May Liu | Cortney Jansen |
| Nigel Rossiter | JoAnna Hunter-Squires |
| Kara Neil |
Sharing Documents, Links, and Meeting Recordings
- Upload files to share with this working group.
- Alternatively, email files or links to Patrick-diamond@intuitive-foundation.org.
- All working group files are stored in this Dropbox folder.
- Access past Meeting Recordings.
Discussion Board
This is a comment on the discussion board. We’d like comments in on the current draft by Sunday
New version from the Dec5 meeting now in the link
Version 5b of Evidence up there for Tuesday’s conversation. The discussion is long and needs some cutting down, but I was running out of steam. The checklists need some serious discussion. That will be the topic of the meeting.